Bobby Abreu. I have no idea how this dude only made two All-Star teams. During his peak–which was from 1998 to 2011–he hit .295/.399/.484 and averaged 20 HR and 28 stolen bases. That is good for an OPS+ of 131. His 61.6 career WAR ranks 93rd all time.
I am happy to see that he showed up in a couple of Topps products this past season.